BOOK REVIEW: Moby Dick by Herman Melville

I have a confession to make. Before I got my Kindle I wasn’t particularly well-read. I had read an awful lot but when it came to any kind of classic literature there was a big hole in my repertoire. As most of you will know you can download books that have fallen into the public domain (i.e. out of copyright) for free. That includes a whole bunch of classic novels. So when I first got my Kindle I downloaded loads of famous works of literature, which I have been working through interspersed with assignments from book club, questionable Young Adult fiction and Game of Thrones. Some of them I absolutely fell in love with – Jane Eyre, Pride and Prejudice,  The Three Musketeers and absolutely everything Sherlock Holmes being among the favourites. Others have been less good and I don’t think I would recommend Madame Bovary or Tess of the D’Ubervilles to anyone.

Moby Dick is my latest foray into classic literature exploration.

Call me Ishmael…

Opening with one of the most well-known lines in English literature, the tale of the whale comes through the eyes of one of the crew of the Pequod, a whaler that has sailed from Nantucket under the command of Captain Ahab. Ishmael has joined the crew in search of adventure along with “savage”, Queequeg who he has bonded with while waiting for a passage. Once on the boat the two friends discover that Ahab has lost his leg at the hands (fins) of a particular sperm whale known as Moby Dick and that he is hell bent on revenge. As the voyage continues the Pequod crosses paths with several other boats, some whales come to a sticky end and Ishmael realises that Ahab will stop at nothing to track and kill Moby Dick even if that leads to the destruction of the boat and all it’s crew.

I’m not quite sure what I was expecting from Moby Dick but I definitely wasn’t expecting it to be 40% biology textbook, 40% whaling/sailing manual and 10% of Ishmael’s somewhat random stories. That’s not to say it’s bad but it is very dense and with extremely limited knowledge of any kind of sea venturing (I don’t think a week of island hopping around Croatia counts) I often found myself somewhat lost. I do now know more about whales that I could ever imagine possible and I did find it very interesting that Ishmael is absolutely focused on killing whales for profit while simultaneously being fascinated by them and to some extent revering them. I also didn’t think there was going to be so much homoeroticism in the beginning or that it would disappear so suddenly.

Despite not being a critical success at the time Moby Dick went onto become one of the Great American novels with readers fascinated by its genre-bending exploration of everything from class structures to mental health issues, religion and the concept of good and evil. All of which I felt like I was really getting into at some points beccause some of the prose is so beautiful but at other points felt utterly overwhelmed by because there was just so very much of it with so many digressions and diversions.

Anyway it hasn’t been one of my favourite classics and I’m not sure I would recommend it unless you’re really into the ocean, or whales or extremely dense prose but I’m glad I read it.




  1. Look at you reading classics! 🙂 Yeah…. This isn’t a classic I’m too bothered about forcing myself to read.

    1. abbiosbiston

      This definitely hasn’t been my favourite but some of the ones I have read are definitely classics for a reason. Another one I would highly recommend that I forgot to mention in my post is Gone With the Wind.

      1. Hmm. I’d never have thought to check that one out. I’m really not well read on the classics. I have a hard time forcing myself to read them! When I have, it’s been stuff like 1984 & Brave New World. Those are more me than things like Pride & Prejudice. (I assume. I’ve not read that…) 😉

        1. abbiosbiston

          Pride and Prejudice is actually very accessible and I can highly recommend it but there are some great modern classics too. Have you read The Handmaid’s Tale?

          1. Nope – not read that either… Worth it?? I don’t know anything about that one!

            1. abbiosbiston

              Really good. It’s a dystopian feminist novel.

              1. Ohh… Sounds like just my cup of tea! 🙂

  2. They should make some kind of movie out of this.

  3. This is one that I always look at and then never read. It seems like there are a lot of good things about it but I just can’t convince myself to do it. I was really tempted when Scully named her dog Queequeg in the X-Files but then I talked myself out of it. Haha!

    1. abbiosbiston

      I can imagine like with most classics some people will think it is incredible and others will find it completely overrated. I actually really enjoyed the beginning where there was lots of Queequeg because he is such a fascinating character. But then you barely hear from him once he’s on the voyage and that kind of disappointed me.

  4. Hmmm, I still haven’t seen the film version but I’d rather see that than read the book. I just think all the details might be over my head. I tried to read Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina but I only got about half of it. I do love Jane Eyre (esp after meeting Rochester) and most of Jane Austen stuff.

    1. abbiosbiston

      I will happily admit that I had several moments where I got quite lost while reading this and I referred to the Wikipedia article on it a few times. It’s just so full of sailing terminology that is incomprehensible if you’ve never actually gone to sea.

      Rochester is super sexy!

  5. I admit I haven’t read Moby Dick. But it’s on my list for one day.

  6. I’m in the same boat. Not so great at reading Classics. Moby Dick is on my to-read list for this year. Hopefully it’ll be good.

    1. abbiosbiston

      I think there’s enough good stuff in there to make it worth reading plus it’s weirdly educational.

  7. jennypugh

    I also haven’t read this yet, but I’ll be adding it to my Kindle list now 🙂

    1. abbiosbiston

      I’d love to hear your views on it.

  8. Gotta confess, I still haven’t read Moby Dick yet…

    And I LOVE Kindle for the fact that it has been able to open up a whole new avenue of reading!

    1. abbiosbiston

      I think Moby Dick is worth reading but I mean it’s not going anywhere so no rush, right? 😛

      1. LOL! I suppose that is one way to look at it!

  9. It was a great read when I was a schoolboy, and the (Gregory Peck) film version is worth seeing too. I wrote a very short bit about it on my blog here.
    Best wishes, Pete.

abbiosbiston is listening...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.